PUSH FOR SCOTUS TO WEIGH IN ON APPLIANCE BAN
Thursday, November 19, 2026

Gas industry asks SCOTUS to weigh in on appliance ban

View Article on PoliticoPro

By Mona Zhang | 11/17/2026 04:27 PM EST

Unions and industry groups challenging a ban on gas appliances in new buildings in New York are seeking an audience at the Supreme Court after the Second Circuit Court of Appeals ruled against them in June.

The Second Circuit consolidated a pair of cases — one challenging the gas appliance ban in New York City, and another challenging a similar law in New York State. The appeals court’s decision backing the laws created a clear split with the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, which struck down Berkeley, California’s ban on natural gas hookups in new buildings in 2023.

“This is not the kind of circuit split that can safely be left for another day,” read the plaintiffs’ petition seeking review by the Supreme Court. “Allowing the split to fester would interfere with the policy Congress adopted.”

The details: The key issue before the courts is whether local and state bans on gas appliances are preempted by the Energy Policy and Conservation Act, which sets federal energy efficiency standards for household appliances.

The Ninth Circuit found that local laws banning gas appliances in new buildings are preempted by the EPCA because it effectively caps gas appliances’ energy use at zero. Conversely, the Second Circuit found that banning gas appliances does not concern “energy use” as EPCA defines it.

While the plaintiffs in the New York case agree with the Ninth Circuit’s ruling, “either way, the divide is untenable,” their Supreme Court petition reads. “What everyone agrees was supposed to be one nationwide rule of preemption now preempts gas appliance bans on the West Coast while allowing them in New York.”

The bigger picture: Similar cases are moving forward in the Fourth, Seventh and D.C. Courts of Appeals. The New York plaintiffs are urging the Supreme Court to take up the issue now, before waiting for those appeals to be decided.

There is no “reason to think that waiting for more circuits to cast their votes would meaningfully contribute to the debate or aid this Court’s review,” the plaintiffs’ petition argues. “Courts and litigants have already coalesced around just two positions.”

What’s next: Once the Supreme Court dockets the case in the coming days, respondents will have 30 days to file their opposition brief. While there isn’t a set deadline for the court to decide whether it will hear a case, it generally makes a decision a few months after a case is docketed.

RSS News Feed
Top News

News Archive

To see previous articles please click here .